This changeset allows app commands defined inside Cog to work as
expected. Likewise, by deriving app_commands.Group and Cog you can
make the cog function as a top level command on Discord.
Segments where readability was hampered were fixed by appropriate
format skipping directives. New code should hopefully be black
compatible. The moment they remove the -S option is probably the moment
I stop using black though.
This bug was kind of a long one to figure out, as per #1918 documents
the issue had to do with subcommands but the actual adventure in
finding this one was a long one.
The first problem was that Command.cog was for some reason None, which
indicated that a copy was happening somewhere along the way. After some
fiddling I discovered that due to the copies of `Cog.__cog_commands__`
the groups pointed to out-dated versions that got overriden by the new
copies.
The first attempt at fixing this was straightforward -- just remove the
subcommand from the parent and replace it with the newer reference that
we just received. However, this ended up not working due to a strange
mystery where the subcommand being invoked was neither the original
copy nor the new copy residing in `Cog.__cog_commands__`.
Some more investigation later pointed out to me that a copy occurs
during the `Group.copy` stage which calls `Command.copy` for all its
subcommands. After spotting this out I had realised where the
discrepancy comes from. As it turns out, the subcommand copy that was
being invoked was actually a stale one created from `Group.copy`.
The question remained, how come that one was being called? The problem
stemmed from the fact that when the subcommand was copied, the parent
reference pointed to the old parent. Since the old parent was the one
that was getting the new reference, it went practically untouched. This
is because the calling code fetches the child from the parent and the
old parent is nowhere in the call chain.
To fix this issue we needed to update the parent reference, and in
order to do that a temporary lookup table is required pointing to the
latest copies that we have made.
Thus ends a 3.5 hour bug hunting adventure.
Bryan Forbes
Rapptz
z03h
Stocker
Josh
mniip
thetimtoy
Nadir Chowdhury
Nihaal Sangha
SebbyLaw
Michael
Dan Hess
Jaime Garcia Jr
Xua